Postby justTripn » Wed Dec 27, 2006 2:46 pm
We should be more charitable to the mix of authors who wrote these stories under a stressful deadline, one a week. The most eye-opening Star Trek reference book I own is the Star Trek Deep Space Nine Companion. It gives a summary of each episode followed by a long discussion by the writers of that epside of their what their intentions were, whether it worked, and how they came up with the ideas. I devoured this book and was amazed. You know how they wrote Deep Space Nine? They MADE IT UP AS THEY WENT ALONG. All these really perfect plot twists that I seemed like part of the backstory were invented on the spur of the moment to solve and immediate problem: that Bashir was genetically engineered; that Kira's mother had had an affair with Dukat. The affair between Ky Wyn and Dukat in disguise happened because one writer said, "wouldn't it be hilarious if we could get these two in bed together" and another one said "why not?" and they all said "YEAH, LET's do it." Of course Kira ended up carrying the O'Brian's baby because the actress got pregnant. One of the writers was moaning to his wife about how this screwed everything up and the WIFE suggested the brilliant solution. And then there are those haunting lines. Garak's statement that "Its all true, especially the lies" and Sisko's line "I am of Bajor." The writers explaining themselves said, "I had no idea what it meant at the time, but it sounded great!" But that's how they commited themselves for future stories.
So what I'm saying is the writers are human so we could go in circles all day working out the inconsistencies. Instead lets just pick whatever works best for the stories.